Monday, April 6, 2015

Study Finds Frackers Averaging 2.5 Violations a Day

Dan Heyman, Public News Service (PA)

PHOTO: A new study of online records for just three states found fracking companies committed an average of two-and-a-half violations of drilling rules a day. Photo courtesy of the Sierra Club.
PHOTO: A new study of online records for just three states found fracking companies committed an average of two-and-a-half violations of drilling rules a day. Photo courtesy of the Sierra Club.
HARRISBURG, Pa. - On average, fracking companies commit more than two-and-a-half environmental violations a day, according to a new study drawn from just a small portion of available public record information.

The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) studied five years' worth of online reports for Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Colorado. According to report co-author and NRDC policy analyst Amy Mall, she and her team totaled up at least 4,600 citations – about 18 per week.

She says some of the 68 drillers they looked at ran up hundreds of violations, including wastewater spills, well leaks and pipeline ruptures.

"When companies are seriously violating the law on a regular basis, they're what we would call a repeat offender," says Wall. "They need to be shut down or they need to be prohibited from getting new permits."

Mall says the study didn't examine the records from the 33 states that don't post citations on-line. And she says they didn't include all the companies doing hydraulic fracturing, which suggests the violations they found are just a fraction of the total.

According to Mall, the fact that most of the public record is inaccessible means it's out of reach for most people. She says this covers a variety of violations, some of which are of immediate public interest.

"It could be contamination of a drinking water source," she says. "It could be a pit that overflowed. It could be not having the right paperwork on site. It really varies quite widely."

The oil and gas industry says the NRDC study includes a lot of "paperwork violations" over what they call clerical issues. Mall says some of those can actually be pretty important.

"If it was information on what chemicals might be used, or whether a well passed a certain type of an integrity test, even a paper violation could be quite serious," she says.

Of the three states the NRDC examined, Pennsylvania had by far the most violations. Mall says that may have as much to do with how the state enforces their rules as anything else.

No comments:

Post a Comment